Monday, 30 November 2015

Sugar, Spice and All Things Nice



"We would rather own Holdsport, Nike, Under Armour, businesses that are working to make you healthier, equally Discovery, rather than producers of products that global bodies are trying to reduce your intake thereof. Make sense? British American Tobacco also falls within the no go category for us. So far we have been wrong on that but it will come."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. There and back yesterday on the Jozi all share, the biggest stories of the day were undoubtably the climate talks in Paris. And at exactly the same time, as the FT pointed out in an article I read, giant smog clouds descended over the capital cities of the two most populous countries on the planet, namely China and India. Those two countries desperately need to uplift their respective populations, their energy needs and mix will be vastly different to those of the developed world.

In the developed world there are more reasons to worry about climate control, your infrastructure is built and your intensive industries have developed to a point where the laws and rules for environmental controls are stricter. For instance, with all due respect to the countries involved, the environmental laws will undoubtably be stricter in Denmark than the DRC, Japan than in Java, it is not to say that these issues shouldn't be taken more seriously in all territories.

How can you tell India to be stricter on emissions controls when around 30 percent of the population lives below the poverty line, a number not too dissimilar to here in South Africa? There are bigger social problems to overcome, full tummies, jobs, shelter, access to basic services seem a whole lot more important than clean air, perhaps that is a basic human right, access to clean resources. Ironically the consequences of climate change often impact those that are marginalised, so we have to care more, a two pronged approach.

We should all try a little harder, be more energy efficient, recycle more, I think that is happening. Resources ironically need to become more scarce, i.e. the economics need to dictate to us. In other words, like we are seeing with solar panels, their conversion, adoption, battery storage capacity, etc. The costs are falling at a rate of knots, relative to the mainstream technologies. Our preferred investments in this space, and they certainly are out there, is SolarCity and Tesla, ironically both companies are associated with Elon Musk, who might have been schooled in these parts (and we call him our own), Charlize is really more South African. Although she picked up some funny accent along the way, what happened there?

There was of course other news, there was a name and version change for Steinhoff, it is effectively an inward listing now. What does that mean? Here is your refresher, we wrote about this back when the company released their FY numbers, here goes: " ... the company announced that they had got the necessary votes to proceed with the offshore listing in Frankfurt. Logistically speaking, what happens next is that a business called Genesis N.V. will acquire all the shares of Steinhoff, in exchange for each Steinhoff listed share on the Frankfurt stock exchange, there will no doubt be a version change. You will basically be an investor, owning a global depositary receipt of a business listed in Frankfurt and domiciled in the Netherlands. Got it? Easy, not so?"

The share code has now changed from SHF to SNH, which stands for Steinhoff International Holdings N.V. The N.V. part stands for naamloze vennootschap, which translates to public company, and according to Wikipedia is used only in the Netherlands (obviously), Belgium, Aruba, Curacao (accent left off the second c, apologies), Suriname, St. Maarten, and Indonesia. The stock actually flew up the charts, up four and a half percent, last week was not a particularly good week for the company, perhaps the ebbs and flows of it all, or perhaps out of certain indices and into others created natural sellers and natural buyers.

In other company news there was Illovo who pointed to the poor weather as something that has really impacted on their business, they are of course not alone. I would not own the business, their core product is one that most diets agree should not be included, it is not good for you, obviously there are still many studies to be done. Some would argue that everything in moderation is ok.

Earlier this year the World Health Organisation (WHO) urged people to reduce their sugar intake, check it out: WHO calls on countries to reduce sugars intake among adults and children. Isn't that a bit of a dumb headline? Adults and children, are you not one or the other? Just recently too the WHO released this: Q&A on the carcinogenicity of the consumption of red meat and processed meat. We would rather own Holdsport, Nike, Under Armour, businesses that are working to make you healthier, equally Discovery, rather than producers of products that global bodies are trying to reduce your intake thereof. Make sense? British American Tobacco also falls within the no go category for us. So far we have been wrong on that but it will come.

And then lastly on the company front, perhaps a story that was underreported and more important than almost anything else going on globally was that the Brazilian government were mulling fining BHP Billiton and Vale (the Brazilian Iron Ore giant) 5.2 billion Dollars for the Samarco operation dam burst. Someone needs to fit the bill for cleaning up a huge environmental disaster. What is astonishing for me is that the size of the fine is about the same as the one levied on MTN for not disconnecting sim cards.

When the fine fits the punishment I have no problem, in this case the burst dam has seen a loss of life and a significant displacement of hundreds of people, the longer term environmental impact is yet to be felt. In BHP's defence, they deny that the tailings had heavy metals and toxic chemicals in them, suggesting that they had checked. The BHP Billiton share price in London fell to a 10 year low. Against of course the backdrop of a complete rout of commodity stocks. We continue to avoid all of these businesses.

Over the seas and far away in New York, New York, stocks started the last day of the second last month on a better footing, unfortunately slipping away after mid afternoon. That Fed meeting and the pending hike will no doubt capture the imagination of market participants for the better part of two weeks. First however is the small matter of the most hyped, most highly anticipated event in equity markets across the world, the release of the non-farm payrolls, officially known as the Employment Situation. A stronger than anticipated number would definitely lead to 100 percent stamp of surety that the Fed are going to hike rates in mid December. The meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) ends on the 16 of December, a holiday here in South Africa. And the local currency has been obliterated relative to the US Dollar, so have many currencies across the globe. Year-to-date the Rand is 8.7 percent weaker to the Euro, over 20 percent to the US Dollar.

Other noteworthy news, and the Euro being the obvious loser was the inclusion of the Chinese Renminbi into the SDR basket. Huh? SDR stands for Special Drawing Right, and according to the inter-webs (that will explain these things better than me): "The Special Drawing Right (SDR) is an international reserve asset, created by the IMF in 1969 to supplement the existing official reserves of member countries. The SDR is neither a currency, nor a claim on the IMF. Rather, it is a potential claim on the freely usable currencies of IMF members." The official IMF release is here: IMF's Executive Board Completes Review of SDR Basket, Includes Chinese Renminbi.

All this means is that the IMF have recognised the Chinese currency as a reserve, a decade after the real Chinese growth started to ramp up. Admittedly this only changes every five or so years, herewith the "new" formula:

    U.S. dollar 41.73 percent (compared with 41.9 percent at the 2010 Review)
    Euro 30.93 percent (compared with 37.4 percent at the 2010 Review)
    Chinese renminbi 10.92 percent
    Japanese yen 8.33 percent (compared with 9.4 percent at the 2010 Review)
    Pound sterling 8.09 percent (compared with 11.3 percent at the 2010 Review)



I for one still don't understand how the Chinese currency trades, whilst it floats and is supposedly free, it is certainly managed by the central bank, the People's Bank of China. Quite right, the direct translation of Renminbi is the people's currency. As apposed to? Fun to watch, nice to be part of that history, until the Dollar changes significantly it will still be the currency that is most widely accepted worldwide. Even in the heart of the cold war, what did people want behind the iron curtain? Dollars. Capitalism wins every single time, and with the liberalisations in the Chinese economy, this is being recognised by the IMF, the International Monetary Fund. A question that should be asked is, how would Chairman Mao Zedong feel about all of this, he is after all the face of the Yuan notes?




Linkfest, lap it up

With wealth comes the ability to take bigger risks. In this case it is taking bigger risks to try push us forward in our consumption of energy, to consume clean energy - Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos and other tech titans form the Breakthrough Energy Coalition to invest in zero-carbon energy technologies. The one thing that Gates says which I feel is very important is: "Our primary goal with the Coalition is as much to accelerate progress on clean energy as it is to make a profit.". Being profitable will make the project sustainable and will also make it possible to attract more talented people to the project.

Here is a look at what global energy supply looks like and the carbon emissions that come with them. It is amazing to see how much more power we consume - As appetite for electricity soars, the world keeps turning to coal. The one thing to remember about electric cars is that at the moment most of them are essentially powered by coal and with a single charge equating to around a months power use of your fridge at home, they have a high electricity demand. As the likes of Bill Gates invests in renewable energy production and as scale makes it cheaper than coal, electric cars will become cleaner.



Josh Brown points out the phenomenon of momentum in asset prices. The basics are that when something is hot or doing well, it gets an extra boost as people all run towards it - The Trouble With Chasing Hot Strategies. It seems to be a phycological trait where we want to get in on the hot action and get out of the things that are doing poorly. The problem is that what normally happens is we buy a stock/strategy at the top and sell a stock/ strategy at the bottom. The cure is to stay calm and patient, short term noise always passes.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks across Asia are higher across the board, some December cheer. US futures are up sharply. The reason given is apparently Asian cheer of the regions prominence, the Asian economic Tiger has clearly arrived. I am not too sure what the Indians think of all of this. India have Ravichandran Ashwin, who is now the second best bowler in the world. China as far as I know have no cricketers of prominence, although the left arm leg spinners googly is known as a chinaman. Stick that in your pipe and smoke it.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Father Christmas is Online



"What is also very important to note is how much money the company is spending in their newer business segments that don't necessarily make money. They spend 37 percent of all development spend (3.5 billion Rand in the last half) on Etail, 31 percent of classifieds and 17 percent on other ecommerce ventures"




To market to market to buy a fat pig. Friday was the slowest day of the year for the US marketers, due to it being Thanksgiving weekend and Friday only being a half day on the the markets. If you went anywhere near a shop on Friday you would have seen chaos ensuing due to the "Black Friday" specials given by local retailers. Never let an opportunity for a good sale slip by. I remember last year there were a couple specials for local retailers and then this year my inbox was full of promotions and Twitter was covered with pictures of throngs of people braving long queues to get their hands on deeply discounted items. In the US, numbers showed that online sales were up 18% this year with 33% of the sales generated from mobile. The numbers are broken down further to show that 71% of those sales happened on iOS (Apple) and only 28% on Android. Given all that data, the consumer who's eyeballs you want are iPhone users.

The shopping is not over though, today is Cyber Monday. According to Wikipedia Cyber Monday originated in 2005 and was an attempt to push sales online. Due to a lack of size and scale, online stores were not able to offer the same specials as brick and mortar stores on Black Friday. Now however the likes of Amazon are bigger than most retail outlets and people tend to spread their shopping over a number of days due to more frequent specials for retailers.

Looking here in Jozi, Jozi we were down on Friday with commodity stocks leading the charge lower. Anglo American down 5.3%, Glencore down 3.8% and BHP Billiton down 3.3%. Having a look at how BHP Billiton is trading in Aus this morning, it is down 3.6% at the moment so expect it to be down at the market open. Bloomberg were reporting this morning that the Iron Ore price was under further pressure this morning, which does not bode well for the likes of Kumba (Anglo American) and BHP Billiton. For a sense of perspective, here is the 30 year price graph for Iron Ore, thanks to Index Mundi. As you can seen, current prices are still much higher than they have been for the bulk of the last 30 years. So if you are buying commodity stocks because you feel they are at the bottom of the cycle, there may be some more pain in the near future.






Company corner

Naspers, one of our most widely and largest holdings across our client base reported their half year numbers on Friday afternoon at 4. Forget Thanksgiving and the half day in the US, forget that we are in festive season, at least for the office and school segment, this is Naspers time. If you were not there to see it, you missed out. Revenues for the half increased 24 percent to 74.29 billion Rand, trading profits increased 34 percent for the half, the metrics at face value look amazing. Core HEPS increased by 40 percent to 21.33 Rand, up from 15.28 Rand this time last year. Revenues have now grown at a compounded annual growth rate of 33 percent for the last four full financial years, it is pretty astonishing. Where are the revenues coming from? Here goes, a series of graphics from the investor presentation all through from segment, geography and then a further breakdown of revenues by type of activity.



What is amazing to notice is that print has been left in the dust, it is becoming a smaller and smaller part of the overall business. It is now all internet and all video entertainment. Breaking down that even further, see the image below, you see the sticky subscription business is one quarter (your DSTV subscription is included in there).



What is IVAS and games? IVAS = internet value-added services. Which is related too your entertainment experience. Wikipedia has the value-added services as the following: "A value-added service (VAS) is a popular telecommunications industry term for non-core services, or in short, all services beyond standard voice calls and fax transmissions. However, it can be used in any service industry, for services available at little or no cost,[citation needed] to promote their primary business."

And then below, revenue by geography, obviously the picture is skewed towards Tencent, in other words Asia. And then here locally, the business is 25 percent South African. In other words, the prospects of the group will be determined by the fortunes of Tencent in the short term.



What is also very important to note is how much money the company is spending in their newer business segments that don't necessarily make money. They spend 37 percent of all development spend (3.5 billion Rand in the last half) on Etail, 31 percent of classifieds and 17 percent on other ecommerce ventures. Only three percent on print, whilst they realise that tv is changing, Michael at his new home only has Showmax. No sport. Ag shame. Video entertainment constitutes 12 percent of all development spend.

I think that the reason why the stock may have sold off on Friday, after this earnings announcement is twofold. One, the share price has obviously been on a tear since the Tencent results, as well as the trading update, both those two events were favourably received and perhaps a little wind out of the sails after the announcement. Secondly, and perhaps more of the reason, was that the company announced that they were going to be thinking about a 2.5 billion Dollar capital raise, dates as of yet unknown. In part to use for the purchase of part of Avito, 1.2 billion Dollars of that. Avito is the leading classifieds website in Russia, a bold move in itself, things are hardly "settled" there.

Why own this business? It has so many moving parts, as well as being nearly completely correlated to a single business, and that obvious share price, Tencent. I noticed the shift to the internet even over the weekend, the so called Black Friday sales in the US. Traditional old school retailer Walmart did the unthinkable, shifting discounts to their website, even before their doors had opened. We are continuing to move more and more to an online platform for entertainment, classifieds, shopping, news and all sorts and increasingly more so on our mobile phones. I think that you just have to learn to live with the volatility of the newer business segments, that continue to burn cash at heavy rates, those are going to be the businesses that compete at a global level with the likes of Amazon, just not in the english speaking world. We continue to recommend Naspers, even at these elevated levels (there will be a PE unwind in the coming years) as a core part of your portfolio.




Linkfest, lap it up

Amazon have used their newest star, Clarkson to walk us through what using drones to deliver packagers would look like - Amazon Prime Air. It would be great to have packagers delivered in under 30min, the first step though is for Amazon to get regulatory approval in the US.

For paper producers, the big shift in the industry is towards Cellulose. Cellulose Nanofiber is 5 times stronger than steel and a fraction of the weight, so you can see the huge potential for this technology. For now its first commercial use is to reduce the odour's in adult nappies - Nippon Paper Sets Nanofiber Diapers as Path to Boost Growth

If this technology works, it will be a game changer for any device using batteries. One of the biggest benefits will be to the electric car market, being able to charge your car in a fraction of the current time will make them more practical - New chip will charge your phone in under 10 minutes.

Lower oil prices means more money in the consumers pocket - Consumer Spending Rises Less Than Forecast as Americans Save. Saving hurts the retailers in the short run but it creates a stronger base for the future which should result in more spending.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. The week ahead holds the start of December and the start of holiday mode for most in South Africa. For the markets it jobs week, where we get the ADP number on Thursday and then the big number on Friday from the US labor department, the employment report. Will employment numbers improve or get worse? How does that effect what the FED will do in their next meeting? No doubt it will be a market moving number and expect the Rand to react.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Thursday, 26 November 2015

There are no Tigers in Nigeria

"The fact of the matter is that the company made a significant investment mistake in Nigeria, the only good news for shareholders is that this is now history, a bad chapter in their history. And ours as shareholders, we have a right to be peeved to a certain extent."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. With the US markets closed yesterday for a celebration of family and collectiveness, thanksgiving, our markets were bound to be quiet. We did rally during the course of the day, up 0.61 percent on the Jozi all share by the close of trade. Resource stocks were mixed, some heavyweights at the top of the leaderboard, South32, Glencore, Amplats and Anglo themselves, BHP Billiton right at the opposite end of the spectrum, the news of the dam burst at Samarco gets worse. The UN suggested that a high level of toxic waste has been found in the waste that spilled from the dam, both metals and chemicals. With hundreds of kilometres of water impacted by the spills, the cleanup costs and fines for BHP Billiton could be less than not disconnecting unregistered sims in Nigeria could run into the billions. That was cheeky.

A correction, a reader of the letter brought to our attention two things, when we were discussing Anglo American and Mondi: "Good morning team - your point is well made, but the situation is even more skewed as Mondi's market cap is actually R158bn, and parity was passed a little while ago. And, keep in mind that Mondi unbundled Mpact in June 2011, so you could add a further R7.5bn." The market cap of the collective Mondis, Mondi Plc. is at 120 billion Rand (as at close last evening) and Mondi Limited is at 38.5 billion, collective at the number the reader pointed out. Add in MPact as he points out, it is an extra 7.5 billion Rand to the collective value, 166 billion Rand in total. Anglo was up sharply yesterday, up 3.88 percent, with the market cap now nearly 130 billion Rand. Thanks for pointing that out, we always appreciate your feedback!

Another conversation that I had with a client yesterday is also worth sharing, he raised concerns over MTN, rightfully so, the stock has been a significant laggard in our client portfolios, we have consistently suggested that until we know something, we know very little other than there is a pending fine, that at face value looks ridiculous. A traffic violation that gets a 400 year sentence is the analogy that a Nigerian blogger used early on in this unfinished business. I think that in my answer (I have left out client sensitive information), again I was a little forceful with the way that the Nigerian authorities have handled this.

" ... the situation has been poorly managed, and perhaps MTN tried to call the regulators bluff. If this is the case, then no doubt that is why Sifiso Dabengwa fell on his sword.

There are plenty of reasons to sell the company today, as you point out, the news flow has been increasingly negative.

The shift of whether or not a fine will be levied (and the quantum) is at the highest office in the land, Muhammadu Buhari, the president. This is a man who was once the dictator of Nigeria in the eighties and the man that also took half a year from being elected (this year) to appoint a cabinet. Yet, the people of Nigeria elected him and knew all of this, and that part we must and should respect.

That said however, MTN are an important part of the Nigerian economy, 46 percent of all subscribers in Nigeria use their services. MTN operate in a hostile economic environment, the electricity supply is patchy at best, the infrastructure is poor and they need to be shown to be complying with first world communication authority standards. It seems a little skewed.

Call us optimists here at Vestact, the company has invested more in the Nigerian infrastructure than most foreign companies. They are still putting up 2G base stations in Nigeria, that is how far they are behind. We think that in the end, the stock has baked in a 50-60 percent chance of the full fine being levied against them, we think that the quantum will be reduced, and the fine will be converted to an investment commitment.

In Africa, across our continent, internet penetration is a mere 26 odd percent, somewhere in that region. There is no chance of a big infrastructure roll out of fixed line options any time soon. It will be mobile solutions that connect Africa to the internet, MTN has a massive first mover advantage."

I hope that answers more questions for all of our other clients on the matter.




Company corner

With everything going on we have had to delay the bringing of the Tiger Brands results for a while, apologies. Rather late than never I say. The results themselves are available via the company website, Key financial indicators. As you can no doubt see, the stronger domestic performance, i.e. in South Africa offset the well documented problem business in Nigeria and irregularities at Haco in Kenya, as well as the failure of a key supplier in Mozambique. Remember that not so long ago the company decided not to fund their business in Nigeria any more. School fees. Equally they wrote the business off to nothing, and will carry that business as a discontinued operation.

Total group turnover advanced only 5 percent to 31.6 billion Rand, profits before tax decreased 20 percent to 2.1 billion Rand, as a result of the significant impairment of the Nigerian business. Earnings per share from continuing operations decreased 14 percent to 1068 cents, headline earnings per share from continuing operations decreased one percent to 1786 cents. Wait for it, by another measure, "Adjusted headline earnings per share from continuing operations, excluding the TBCG deferred tax asset impairment, increased by 6% to 1 920 cents". I am not a fan of that, it is comparable to saying, well, if I didn't get 20 percent wrong in that test I would have got an A.

The fact of the matter is that the company made a significant investment mistake in Nigeria, the only good news for shareholders is that this is now history, a bad chapter in their history. And ours as shareholders, we have a right to be peeved to a certain extent. The dividend for the second half is 611 cents (519.35 cents after tax), unchanged from last year, the interim dividend was 10 cents higher, effectively the write offs and the poor performance did not impact on that. Although, you would argue without that, it would be higher.

At a management level, CEO Peter Matlare exits the business in the coming month, the ex CFO in the Nick Dennis era, Noel Doyle was appointed the COO during the course of the year, that should soften the blow somewhat. In fact, Noel Doyle has been appointed as the interim CEO, Matlare will leave 31 December, and the announcement of a new CEO will be made in due course. Do you think that Doyle has a chance for the top job, any Tiger insiders who want to comment there?

The outlook is muted at best, it "remains challenging, with low domestic economic growth, rising costs and job security concerns weighing on the South African consumer. These factors are exacerbated by the weak rand which is fuelling inflationary pressures and intensifying the competitive trading dynamics already evident. The macro-economic outlook for the rest of sub-Saharan Africa is muted, while currency devaluations and foreign exchange liquidity are additional risks. However, Tiger Brands has the brands, people and capability to address these challenges. In addition, the group will continue to focus relentlessly on cost savings and efficiencies, as well as further investment in innovation, customer engagement and brand development."

Notwithstanding that, the share price reacted positively to the results, in other words they were not as bad as many had anticipated, the South African segment performed better than many had penciled in. The market has pencilled in more than 20 Rand worth of earnings inside of this financial year, and around low teen earnings growth the year after, i.e. above 22 Rand worth of earnings in 2017, a long way away to make any predictions with a great deal of accuracy. With dividend cover of around 2 times (that region), the stock yields 3.3 percent forward, pre-tax. Not a kings ransom, better than most on the local front. We continue to hold Tiger Brands in our client portfolios.




Linkfest, lap it up

Interesting to see how much DNA can tell us about our ancestors, what they looked like, where they moved and what they were eating - Agriculture Linked to DNA Changes in Ancient Europe

Given our human bias to want to protect ourselves we tend to give more attention to people that talk about how things are going to get worse, they are great story tellers and seem smart - Covariation Bias and the Bear Market "Genius". As Cullen Roche points out in the blog, there has not been a recorded spider death in Australia (where everything is trying to kill you) since 1979, yet we are still overly concerned about spider bites and death.

As you read this there are many Americans queuing to get their share of the Black Friday deals. Locally retailers are also using Black Friday as a reason to offer specials to try get you to spend some money with that never to be seen again special price - Black Friday Falters as Consumer Behaviours Change. The article highlights how online retail takes a bigger chunk of total sales each year and it makes sense. Who wants to queue and fight the crowds only to find out the product that you really wanted is sold out? Sitting at home sipping coffee, watching sport and doing my shopping online sounds much better!




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Michael pointed out that it is Black Friday today, the US markets are open for half a day. The biggest news for today is without a doubt the Naspers results, that will be released at 16:00 local time, if you are still around, make sure that you look out for that.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Anglo Mondi Parity



"Now here is the amazing part, fast forward to present day where Mondi Plc and Mondi Limited has a collective market capitalisation of 118 billion Rand, Anglo American has a market cap of 124.6 billion Rand. Your 91 Anglo American shares (at 88.71) are worth only 8072.61 Rand at last evenings close, your 25 Mondi Plc shares (321.70 Rand a share) are now worth 8042.5 Rand, whilst your 10 Mondi Limited shares (at 319.85 Rand a share) are now worth 3198.50 Rand, collectively the Mondi shares are 11241 Rand, your Anglo American shares are worth a whole lot less I am afraid to say."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. We closed higher yesterday locally, not by much though. Up nearly one-fifth on the day, there really was a massive divergence between the stocks that were up and those that were down. Again, there was sector specific selling in commodity stocks, Anglo American was at about the lowest price in Rand terms for a decade and a half, I think. I can't recall seeing an Anglo American price below 90 Rand, not in the time that I have been in this industry.

I recall in May of 2003 saying to a then colleague, quickly, get them, they are below 100 Rand. Since then they have unbundled Mondi, though the company acquired a large stake in Kumba Iron Ore. I am not too sure, talking of Kumba Iron, that you can see such a change in fortunes for a specific company. In 2014, the company paid around 35 Rand in dividends. The share price is currently 47.35 Rand. And no, expect not a single cent in dividends this year. And none on the horizon, the iron ore price is visiting lows last seen in 2009.

The short term graph of iron ore prices looks ugly, the price this morning of iron ore indicates more pain, there is a story from the Sydney Morning Herald that has a headline that looks all wrong to me: ASX falls on global unrest, record low iron ore prices. Record low? Err ...... No. The price of iron ore was fluctuating between 11 and 14 Dollars a ton from the early eighties for a period of twenty years. Mind you, the commentary from the quoted person in the article around trading ranges, the Christmas effect, low conviction as a result of lower volumes. It really is SMH (Shake my head).

The most amazing thing in all of this for me is the Mondi unbundling from Anglo American in the middle of 2007, and I will tell you why in a second, see this document from Mondi -> Anglo American plc demerger of Mondi. For every 100 Anglo shares you had (old), you got 91 new Anglo shares and 10 Mondi limited, as well as 25 Mondi plc. 100 Anglo shares in the middle of July 2007 were worth 470 Rand a share each, so about 47 thousand Rand at the time. The 25 Mondi Plc. shares would have been worth 1621 Rand at the beginning (at around 65 Rand a share), the 10 Mondi Limited shares were worth just short of 800 Rand, not exactly a kings ransom here.

Now here is the amazing part, fast forward to present day where Mondi Plc and Mondi Limited has a collective market capitalisation of 118 billion Rand, Anglo American has a market cap of 124.6 billion Rand. Your 91 Anglo American shares (at 88.71) are worth only 8072.61 Rand at last evenings close, your 25 Mondi Plc shares (321.70 Rand a share) are now worth 8042.5 Rand, whilst your 10 Mondi Limited shares (at 319.85 Rand a share) are now worth 3198.50 Rand, collectively the Mondi shares are 11241 Rand, your Anglo American shares are worth a whole lot less I am afraid to say.

A tale of two very different companies in two very different operating environments, where just a decade back they were one and the same. Still, your 47 thousand Rand has turned into less than 20 thousand Rand in a time that the index has definitely done better. Ironically, if you had to ask now which company has the better prospects, I would think that paper and packaging has a better fist of it in the short to medium terms.

And then when you see stories like this one, perhaps a kite flying expedition, reported on Bloomberg: De Beers IPO Could Fetch $10 Billion for Anglo, HSBC Says. As HSBC say, Anglo are waiting for a cyclical recovery before they proceed. Which leads me to believe that dividends from all the majors are under threat.

The market is telling you exactly that, with BHP Billiton trading on a historic dividend yield (in London, in Pounds) of 9.6 percent, that seems too good to be true. Clearly if Mr. Market believed that next year, in a zero interest rate environment, that the company would give you 1 pence for every ten invested, the stock would be snapped up quickly. With predictions of iron ore prices in the 30's (Dollars per ton), the progressive dividend policy is likely to be slashed. I am thinking that BHP's ability to meet some sort of dividend is far superior than Anglo, we continue to however avoid the whole sector. It may take a number of years before the pain passes, it will have to mean many closures for smaller operators, including in the steel industry. Sigh, the deep cycles, when you are at the highs, nothing could ever go wrong.

Over the seas and far away, in New York, New York, blue chips and the broader market really ended flat. Really, they did. Often you can say mixed and lower, in this case you really, really can. The Dow Jones Industrial average closed up 0.01 percent, the broader market S&P 500 closed 0.01 percent lower. Tech stocks, the nerds of NASDAQ, added one quarter of a percent. There was still much global geopolitical risk watching, the exchanges between Turkey and Russia are still front and centre. The French president has been in Washington, he is off to Moscow today as far as I understand it, to deal with the same issues plaguing much of the world, terrorism. Calm has obviously been the order of the day, good news. I had noticed that both Allergan and Pfizer both advanced nearly 3 percent, will the deal happen? The market tells you that there is uncertainty, that seemed to be the most action in a relatively quiet day.




Linkfest, lap it up

It would seem that history points toward a good time for stocks after an interest rate hike. A rise in interest rates normally is coupled with a strong underlying economy. Another reason is from a phycological angle where once the interest rate rising cycle starts, it creates some form of certainty for investors. None of the current back and forth of "Will they, Won't they?" - What History Says About Fed Rate Hike Cycles And Stocks. The circumstances in days gone by when interest rates were hiked previously are by no means the same as they are now, as Sasha always says: "How many iPhones did they sell back then?"

This will be huge for renewable energy and more so for coal producers - Solar power may be cheaper than coal in India by 2020. India is the second biggest country and there is a quiet hope that they will manage to straighten a few things out and get the huge growth that we have seen from China. Based on current trends, it would seem that the growth will be powered by renewable energy and that a huge spike in coal prices is not on the cards.

What consumer technology are the people at Apple dreaming up with the purchase of this company - Apple confirms it bought a motion capture startup used in Star Wars. The company does real-time facial animation, where the camera takes your facial expression and imposes it on an animated character. My guess is that Apple has a plan for the facial recognition part of the software.

Is this one way to bring down health costs? Having 4 birds take a look at the images, they managed to have 99% success rate. The article does not give what the human success rate is but even doctors make mistakes - Pigeons identify breast cancer 'as well as humans'. Would you be happy for a bird to decide if you have cancer or not?




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks have started better this morning, stocks across Asia are mixed to better. The futures market is slightly higher, which is where we would love the cricket match to be. Everyone is bleating about that pitch. I have read literature about uncovered pitches, the equipment is better. It can't always be suited for batters, not so? It is Thanksgiving today, I do not plan on eating any turkey, it is not part of my scene. Black Friday tomorrow, perhaps that is many peoples scene, shopping, people love that stuff. I did notice that several of our local online retailers started pushing Black Friday. It is going to be quiet out there, on account of US markets being closed today and then half day tomorrow.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Tuesday, 24 November 2015

Primary sector irrelevance



"As you can see, most economists are bleating, the primary sector of the economy experienced the worst of times recently. The more advanced your economy, the more reliant on technological innovations to drive your primary sector, more industrialised machinery doing the logging, the harvesting, the planting, the maintenance (fertilisers and pesticides) and so on. There may be fewer people doing work in that segment of the economy, that does not mean it is not as important to the rest of the economy."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. It's complicated. More complicated than Ross, Joey, Chandler, Phoebe, Monica and Rachel, all sitting on a couch in their favourite coffee shop, trying to figure what life is all about. That show. In the Middle East it is so complicated that when I tried in my simple way to explain, using history going back, I found myself being spun right round. Like, why exactly is Bashar al-Assad and his dictatorship, friends with the Russians? Equally, why do the Iranians support Bashar al-Assad? How did the Daesh (Islamic State - IS) form and take control over multiple territories and millions of people?

If you read about the precursor to the IS, the leader fought against the Russians in Afghanistan. The history goes a little further back than you think. So why did the Turks down a Russian plane yesterday? The Turks suggested that the Russian plane had violated their airspace, multiple warnings were given. The Russians deny they were in Turkey, they were in Syria, which of course is by "invitation". It is very complicated and very tense, the Russians, NATO, Turkey themselves, the French looking for allies in the area, the involvement of the US in that region for decades, the history goes a little further back, thousands of years. Yip, it truly is complicated.

Markets took a swoon as the news started appearing on the screens, futures fell and the decent enough European GDP numbers (albeit still weak), evaporated along the way. Then later on in the day US GDP numbers were a comfortable beat, revised higher for the third quarter on beefed up inventories. Whilst markets in New York, New York opened much lower, stocks clawed their way back and managed to close marginally in the green on the day. Spurred on by the energy stocks, tensions in the Middle East and geopolitical tensions in general lead to higher energy prices.

On the local front, again it was a mixed bag for stocks, we never got the lift at the end from an improving US session and closed down nearly three-quarters of a percent, most of the day was spent wallowing in the red. Richemont continues to slide, the company no doubt suffering from the strains of cancelled bookings to the city of lights, Paris. There was also a gloomier outlook from Tiffany & Co. in a global world all the stocks I guess are impacted by the same factors. You cannot have it both ways.

Talking of not the best outlook, the local GDP number disappointed yesterday, although as Stats SA pointed out, in nominal terms this is the first time that the number has topped 1 trillion Rand for a quarter. And barring a disaster, I suspect that the next quarter will be better. Bright spots included food and beverages, wood and paper, as segments of the economy. There was obviously pain felt in the agricultural sector, the weather is always something that you cannot control, the mining sector was understandably lower too, with commodity prices having shrunk drastically over the last twelve months and the demand side looking floppy (equally too much supply), the sector might remain muted for some time. In fact, Omnia who operates in that space suggested as much yesterday. There was a nice graphic from Stats SA that is worth sharing.



As you can see, most economists are bleating, the primary sector of the economy experienced the worst of times recently. The more advanced your economy, the more reliant on technological innovations to drive your primary sector, more industrialised machinery doing the logging, the harvesting, the planting, the maintenance (fertilisers and pesticides) and so on. There may be fewer people doing work in that segment of the economy, that does not mean it is not as important to the rest of the economy.

Anyhow, as the divergent US and our local economic numbers, which resemble more European looking number, suggest, we are in a tough patch here. What does help, in my little opinion, is the president telling the far left that the capitalists set the price of bread and oil (it is the market ultimately), and then ask the private sector to invest. I shall reserve judgement and avoid this sensitive area, I have found that in the past there are too many divergent opinions, which is what makes South Africa great, many divergent views. Imagine the level of agreement in Scandinavia relative to here, no wonder they all have similar looking flags.




Linkfest, lap it up

Commercial space travel is now one step closer with the team at Blue Origin managing to land a rocket - The reusable space rocket is nearly here with Blue Origin's first successful landing. You might have not hear of Blue Origin before, it is the space company headed by another pioneer Jeff Bezos.

One of the most influential people of the last decade is Ben Bernanke. His knowledge of economic history helped to avert another great depression - Ben Bernanke on bubbles, bitcoin, and why he's not a Republican anymore. The interview gives a brief insight into his thoughts on politics, monetary policy and fiscal policy.

Here is a look at the largest bankruptcies in history. Lehman makes Enron look like child's play. It is a reminder that things do go wrong and it can happen to huge, very old companies - Largest Bankruptcies in history (Click on the link for a clearer view of the image)

 

One advantage of having a super computer is that it can process vast amounts of data and pick up patterns - IBM wants to predict earthquakes and volcanoes with Watson. To give perspective of how much data needs to be crunched to better understand the what is going on below the surface of the earth: "Were you somehow able to run this model on a regular home computer, it'd take you three years to get a sense of what's going on under the Earth's surface. The Sequoia can do it in a day."




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks across Asia are a mixed bunch, mostly lower other than the Shanghai markets, that has a mind of its own. Although as Byron tweeted the other day, and it is worth looking at almost every single day, the US markets are so colossal, relative to the rest of the world. See here, a tweet from BI Markets: This map shows how some US corporations are worth more than the entire stock markets of other countries. JP Morgan Chase is marginally smaller than the whole of our market. JNJ is worth more than India. As long as we beat India over the next five days, I am happy! What is pretty amazing is that Google and Amazon collectively are bigger than the entire Chinese market. Makes you think about the anxiety of the recent Chinese stock market swoon, not so? Perspective as ever.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063​

Food and Healthcare



"I would choose each and every time the prospects of a hospital group over a tobacco or alcohol company, is it just me that thinks medical care spend is less "optional" than anything else? Mind you, there is one thing that is more addictive than cigarettes as Paul always points out, it is food."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. Whilst it was a mixed bag here in Jozi, stocks ending off a fraction might appear at face value as a failure to ignite, in truth it was almost the best point of the day, the closing. Resource stocks felt an enormous amount of pain, down another three and (nearly) one-third of a percent on the day. Over five years the Resource 10 index, which includes all the majors, is down nearly 49 percent. Wow. Times have changed. And so much so that as far as the ranking tables go, by companies by market capitalisation is that Remgro and Sanlam are, as of this morning, bigger companies than Anglo American. FirstRand is a bigger company than Glencore. Anglo finds itself in 18th place and represents just over 1.1 percent of the overall market. A company that was once synonymous with South Africa has fallen down the ranking tables, in the most dramatic way.

Whilst that slide has been well documented, it is the morbid fascination of humans to focus on negative events (it may happen to you mentality), what is less documented and we have tried to point this out several times, there are always new winners. Businesses like Discovery, that are nearly 100 billion Rand big, from next to zero one quarter of a century ago. Companies like Steinhoff that have pulled off audacious deals, and grown to a business that is more than double Anglo American.

And then one of the biggest metamorphosis shows, Naspers, which clocked a new all time high yesterday. The stock was at the top of the leaderboards, up over three percent on the day to close out at 2233 Rand. This is ahead of results, which I think are on Friday. At the opposite end of the spectrum was Glencore, down 7 percent plus as copper prices plumbed lows last seen near the financial crisis. Equally, South32 was down 5.3 percent, Anglo down 4.2 percent, BHP down over three and one-third of a percent.

Another noticeable loser on the day, bunched in amongst the losers was Netcare, that stock was down 3.81 percent. Year to date the stock is flat, yesterday the company released results for their year to end September. Profits before tax were up 16.4 percent, HEPS rose 12.6 percent to 189 cents, the dividend was hiked by 12.5 percent to 54 cents. Which means by peer comparisons, Netcare is neither expensive nor cheap, Mediclinic, Netcare and Life all trade on low 20 times historic earnings. I read the outlook, it seems just fine to me, prospects although muted in both the UK and here, the company operates in a hugely defensive space. We prefer Mediclinic to Netcare, we are lucky enough to have multiple choices of three quality operators.

I would choose each and every time the prospects of a hospital group over a tobacco or alcohol company, is it just me that thinks medical care spend is less "optional" than anything else? Mind you, there is one thing that is more addictive than cigarettes as Paul always points out, it is food. We have always and will always eat food. If I have to say with certainty that in particular two industries are going to be around in 100 year (for great grandchildren), I would be certain that it is food and healthcare.

Talking food, there were results from Rhodes Foods, who have the best and most peaceful head office in the country on the Pniel Road in the Groot Drakenstein. For those of you who do not know where that is, it is not too far from Franschhoek. Whilst most of you may have heard of that part of the world, how many of you have heard of, what the company refers to as strong brands? The name Rhodes (yes I have), Bull Brand (yes, again), Magpie (maybe), Saint Pie (nope) and Pure Squish (definitely not, perhaps as a result of older children).

Still, the company managed to register sales of 23 percent higher for their full year to end 27 September (weeks and not months in reporting), gross profits increased nearly 29 percent, normalised HEPS showed a monster 136.9 percent increase to 87.4 cents, the maiden dividend of 24.8 cents (raise your bat Rhodes Foods) declared represents a dividend cover of three times. The stock trades on 30 times (nearly) earnings, at that growth rate a PEG of 1 is acceptable, the stock was cheered up 5 percent plus yesterday. The market cap is now a whopping 5.1 billion Rand, bigger than I thought.

Another food company is reporting results this morning, this time Pioneer Foods Sales are up a modest 6 percent to 18.7 billion Rand for the full year, yet the magic of Phil Roux seems to be permeating through the whole business still. Earnings are 17 percent higher to 1.13 billion, diluted HEPS is up 12 percent to 613 cents, the dividend for the full year is much higher, up 52 percent to 332 cents (237 cents in the final dividend). They seem to be focusing on cutting costs, increasing margins, driving returns for shareholders. Whilst we like this business, we prefer Tiger Brands, who have had problems of their own. We are busy compiling a year end results report for our clients.

There are also results from chemicals, agriculture and explosives company Omnia this morning. They do not paint the best outlook for the medium term, in light of a deteriorating mining outlook: "The downturn in the mining sector, which started in the last quarter of the 2014 calendar year continues. In the short-term, the situation is expected to remain weak or to deteriorate further and will probably not turn the corner for another few years."

They are taking it unfortunately on all fronts, the weaker commodity prices equals less demand for explosives, the poor weather means that fertiliser usage has been muted, the weaker economy means chemicals sales growth is unlikely to grow at any pace. Six month sales were flat, profits were nearly 20 percent lower, HEPS dropped 19 percent to 494 cents, dividend marginally lower to 180 cents, that is the only good news. We continue to recommend that you avoid until the outlook improves, judging from their commentary, that might well be a few more years.

Over the seas and far away in New York, New York stocks closed marginally lower, stocks were up sharply at the beginning of the session. Monday merger excitement to begin with, although the stocks in question themselves, Pfizer and Allergan did not gain at all, if anything, both stocks dropped quite a lot. I guess in order to complete the deal and look for the tax inversion in Ireland, and an international footprint for Allergan, this is going to take some doing. The gift that keeps on giving, "the Donald" said that jobs were flying out the window and this was a disgrace. That fellow is a hoot, in fairness to his many critics, myself included, the man has managed to gain a certain amount in the polls. Whether or not this translates to a Republican nomination is debatable, we can only wait. Until then, he gives much amusement to moderate and liberals across the globe.

For an interesting take on what is a HUGE deal and the tax "avoidance", see the Quartz article titled: Pfizer and Allergan just announced the second-largest corporate M&A deal of all time. The article is pretty light on the deal, it does however highlight the tax problem that the US has. And if the mechanism exists to transfer from 35 to 12.5 percent tax rates, then good for the companies involved. Is it a moral issue? I am not too sure, countries attract capital in all the ways that they possibly can. An interesting debate that highlights that the US is not as competitive as they should be.

Staying on Pharma, did you see that Bill Ackman now holds through option structures around 9.9 percent of Valeant, he really is backing that horse in a large way. So much so that it is now the biggest holding in his fund. The stock is down 60 percent in three months, following both the gouging allegations from presidential candidate (and likely next president) Hillary Clinton and the potentially more damaging revenue fudging allegations. And the fact that Charlie Munger does not like their business practices means that Ackman is up against it. He has scored deep on some of his takes before, and equally thrown in the towel on the likes of JC Penney (that went badly). If nothing for us, it provides a little bit of spice.




Linkfest, lap it up

Here is a map of howl long it would take you to travel in 1914 from England. There are many areas on the map that will take you over 40 days to reach! - Time travel.



Moving on to another other form of travel, NASA has placed orders with Space X for crewed rockets. You will remember that Space X is privately owned by Elon Musk, who has the mission to get people to Mars. One of the first steps in doing that is taking people to the International Space Station - NASA orders first crewed mission from SpaceX to the International Space Station.

Josh Brown has a look at the roots of the word risk. He also points out it appears 4 times more in media than the word weather, which I think points to our bias to avoid losses and to avoid pain. The result is we fixate on risk more than we probably should - The Etymology of Risk

There have been many unicorns prancing around Silicon Valley, less so over the last few months though - Tech's big valuation correction means the system is working the way it's supposed to. Sometimes too much money flows in the direction of new technology with the result being that valuations can become too high. In the current environment the money flowing to Silicon Valley is mostly private, which means that when things go bust, the shock wave does not hit the broader market/public. It is great to see huge amounts of money flowing into tech because the new things invented improves all our lives.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks have started mixed here, resource stocks bouncing a little, although it is too hard to tell. There is the small matter of European, US and South African GDP reads today. That should be exciting for the economists out there, established and budding alike. I suspect that we are at a point where we are "waiting for the Fed".




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Monday, 23 November 2015

Brait's New Look

"Byron went to the presentation, he was pretty impressed, the company brought all their company heads in an epic company presentation. The investment company has been exceptionally busy over the last year to year and a half, this period was especially busy. Having sold the Steinhoff shares, and other investments, having raised a lot of money in a convertible bond issuance, the company has proceeded to add to their Icelandic Food business, as well as bed down some of their recent big transactions."




To market to market to buy a fat pig. Markets closed better Friday, both locally and in New York. It was a mixed bag here, again at the top of the leaderboard was Tiger Brands, the follow through from their results indicating that the broader market have stuck their seal of approval on this. Elsewhere a huge bounce from Mr. Price, that stock was down sharply during the course of the week after the results, the Friday session indicated that the buyers had definitely stepped up to the plate, the stock up a whopping 8.7 percent.

The price is still comfortably off the April highs of around 280 Rand, a long road back. Still, I think that the quality of the company will prevail, that fast fashion segment is great. I might buy clothes to last and make sure that I get value for money, many view clothes as a wear for a while item, and then recycle quickly. Talking of clothes and a little off the topic, I read a Fast Company article titled: What's with all the yoga pants? Mr. Price of course has their own ath-leisure brand and have started rolling out their own sports stores. As you can see, athletic wear as a fashion item is huge, people wear sports shirts, pants, tights and so on as every day wear. Comfort for starters, more people partaking in multiple sporting events too, the size and scale of mainstream races is extraordinary.

We closed higher in the last little bit here on Friday, the Jozi all share ending the day one quarter of a percent better than where we started. Across the seas and far away in New York, New York, markets closed off their highs, still managing decent gains on the day. The Dow Jones added just over half a percent, the broader market S&P 500 added 0.38 percent by the close and the nerds of NASDAQ up 0.62 percent on the day. It has been a tough old year for stocks in general, the S&P 500 is up only one and a half percent.

Mind you, we are a world away from those August lows and the washout then, having recovered sharply (a reminder to always be in and not be out). Over five years the S&P 500 has delivered returns of 74 percent pre the dividend, and to be fair, most of the chattering classes have not given this rally much credence, being conditioned to "bad events". And now we are staring at the first rate hike in an absolute age, the anxiety seems to have evaporated a little. The Fed are raising rates as they think the timing is right, the US economy is strong enough and global risks are not as pronounced now as they were earlier in the northern hemisphere summer.

The deal on the cards this morning that will capture much of the attention (as well as the Brussels shutdown) is the news, according to the WSJ that Pfizer, Allergan Agree on Historic Merger Deal. This will make the largest drug manufacturer on the planet. 11.3 Pfizer shares for each and every Allergan share, and a small cash portion too, according to the article that always cites the loudmouth "people familiar with the situation". Most importantly however for US tax authorities, as this is a reverse take-over, the HQ will head to more tax efficient Dublin, this would represent the biggest ever tax inversion in history. I think that the US really needs to be more competitive on the corporate tax front, more and more of these mega-deals will happen and that will be to the gain of the Irish. Who are just there, they just need to turn up.

Why is this a big deal? The 150 billion Dollar deal (Allergen to essentially be acquired by Pfizer) will comfortably eclipse the AB InBev acquisition of SABMiller, that deal is 105.6 billion Dollars big. Is it really a chance for Pfizer to acquire aesthetic therapies in an area they have been lagging, or is it a chance for Pfizer to maintain their presence as numero uno, either way if the deal goes ahead it sends a clear signal that the pharma world continues to remain acquisitive. Anything relatively cheap, anything with a great product pipeline will be an acquisition target. As the article points out, the Allergen product range would become global now with the Pfizer distribution mechanisms. Either way you look at this deal, in the medium to long term it seems good for both sets of shareholders. There may be some big regulatory hurdles to clear, as they say in the classics, "a deal is not a deal until the money is in the till".




Company corner

Brait released their results last week, this was for their six months to end September. Byron went to the presentation, he was pretty impressed, the company brought all their company heads in an epic company presentation. The investment company has been exceptionally busy over the last year to year and a half, this period was especially busy. Having sold the Steinhoff shares, and other investments, having raised a lot of money in a convertible bond issuance, the company has proceeded to add to their Icelandic Food business, as well as bed down some of their recent big transactions. For a quick look at how many moving parts there have been over that time, here is a snapshot of their NAV analysis for 2016, as at the end of the six month period:



You can see that quite simply, in descending order their most important assets are clothing group New Look (45 percent of NAV), health business Virgin Active (they own 78 percent) and this represents 22 percent of the overall NAV, and then their almost all of Premier Foods (management own the rest) equates to 14 percent. The rest of the NAV is made up of Icelandic Foods, 3 percent, and then cash and cash equivalents at 13 percent. The company can only report the values of these businesses when comparing them to their market peer grouping. This is not so simple, as Virgin Active has no real peer in their space.

Their biggest asset, UK based New Look however does have a peer grouping, comparable to H&M (stupid queues at lines at the recently opened Sandton store I am told), Inditex (you would know them as Zara, their flagship brand), as well as the likes of Marks & Spencers and Next. Locally the company is comparable to Mr. Price. As we mentioned, it is not easy to find a peer grouping for Virgin Active, the company is at pains to point this out. Either way, they discount both New Look and Virgin Active to their peer grouping , applying a ten percent discount to New Look and 20 percent to Virgin Active, even more on the spot prices of the listed entities, 13 to 24 percent respectively. Which may explain why the shareholders are willing to apply a premium to the reported NAV, as that is at a discount. Isn't this just the market being efficient and closing the gap?

So why would you want to own this company? The management has shown that they can certainly sniff out the best deals at the right price, sweat those for a period of time and either on-sell them or grow them into larger entities. The recent convertible bond issuance also shows a certain maturity, they have become the first company (to their knowledge) who are able to raise money in this fashion without a main listing in Europe. We recommend again that clients own this stock as a core holding, there are certainly some crossovers with Tiger and Premier, Woolies and New Look, the Virgin Active is exciting and has very little comparable, you could argue that the Discovery Vitality (and white labelling of the product) is comparable. A great business, well run, and whilst it seems like a significant premium to pay, we are comfortable based on the discounted value applied by management.




Linkfest, lap it up

If I had to ask you what was the best performing stock of the last 34 years, I doubt Home Depot would make your top guesses - The Best Performing Stock for the Past 34 Years Will Surprise You. The main thing to note is that the stock had a 71% pull back going into this millennium and then another 50% pull back in 2008, sticking to your guns over the long run is an important strategy to stick to. Sticking to your guns with a stock that is going to zero on the other hand is a problem. The hard part is to know which stock you are holding.

The group of countries that we have been grouped with, BRICs, is on its way out. Here is a look at how quickly things changed in Brazil - Brazilian waxing and waning.

When it comes to what we eat things tend to be a bit more sensitive. In the case of Salmon, the wild reserves are greatly over fished. Here is one of the solutions - U.S. clears genetically modified salmon for human consumption. Would you eat genetically modified fish? What about eating it and not knowing because it is not labeled? We already eat genetically modified fruit and vegetables and there is very little backlash from the consumer. The shift to eating GM food will probably just be another change in our food that people don't notice.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. The centre right folks took over in Argentina, beating the lefties. There is a long way to go to liberalise that economy, I must say that I am pleased that this is happening. The socialists did an enormous amount of damage, so much so that the Dollar is king and gets twice as much buying power in cold hard cash relative to the card swipes, that is just nuts. Brussels is in shutdown mode, this is a new world and we will have to become used to it. Expect selling on the commodities front, the oil glut is now front and centre with idle ships visible.




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063