Showing posts with label Discovery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Discovery. Show all posts

Wednesday, 21 February 2018

The World is Discovering Vitality


Market Scorecard. After their long weekend, US markets were red yesterday. Walmart, a player in both the Dow and S&P 500 was down 10% after poor results! (Walmart just saw $30 billion in market cap destroyed by Amazon fears) The Dow was down by 1.01%, the S&P 500 was down 0.58%, the Nasdaq was down 0.07%, and the All-share was down 1.32%. Bidcorp released their six-month numbers this morning, which the market seemed to like. The stock is currently up 2%.




One thing, from Paul

I always view Budget Day with trepidation. The state has a vital role to play in a healthy society, taking on many functions which are more efficiently handled by public entities. It is vital to save the lives of the poorest of the poor with ongoing social grants, and to provide basic healthcare, schooling, infrastructure and security services. All this has to be funded by taxes, and I'm OK with the idea that rich people should pay more, as often they have had the benefit of generations of state support. I'm also OK with the idea that the democratically elected government of the day should get to decide on its main priorities, within the bounds of the constitution.

However, public entities are seldom run well, and many people go into politics and public service for the money, or to gain control of state resources, and to divert public funds in corrupt ways for their own personal gain. In South Africa, it's hard to find an organ of state which isn't in a state of crisis.

Tax revenues have slipped badly in the last decade, and SARS's credibility has plummeted, but state spending has roared ahead. Our public sector wage bill is huge and rising (but productivity is poor). Add to that the ghastly capital spending overruns at Eskom, and we are facing a dire fiscal shortfall. South Africa's debt to GDP ratio has spiralled out of control.

Spending needs to be cut, but that is hard for politicians. So, expect tax hikes today. That's on top of last year's unfortunate hike in the top marginal income tax rate to 45%, and the recent increases in both dividend withholding taxes and capital gains taxes.

This is really Cyril Ramaphosa's greatest challenge. It's very nice to go walking in the morning with the people, but can he take the hard decisions that are required to put our country back on a sustainable fiscal path?




Company Corner

Byron's Beats

Yesterday Discovery released their interim results for the six months ending 31 December 2017. As expected from the trading update, the numbers looked good. Operating profit increased by 19% while normalised headline earnings per share increased by 31% to R4.11. The big drivers behind the growth in earnings was a solid showing from the UK business as well as profits coming through for the first time from the short-term insurance business as well as the Ping An joint venture.

The image below shows the contribution of each segment.



As always, Adrian Gore was very confident and passionate. He didn't skip a beat in his presentation. You can see he truly believes in his product and is genuinely proud that it is making the world a better place.

The local businesses all did well in a tough environment. Discovery Health and Life are the bread and butter of this business. As you can imagine, growth has slowed, but they are still stealing market share. If our economy goes through a growth spurt, these businesses will thrive. That includes Discovery Insure and Discovery Invest who have both leveraged off a good brand and some great incentive schemes.

Vitality UK is finally doing well. They now have over 1 million lives insured in a country where healthcare is mostly free. When your friends are getting free Apple watches, Starbucks coffees and discounted gym contracts because they exercise three times a week, the clients become the best salesmen. The preventative healthcare model is genius. It is cheaper and far better for your standard of living, to prevent than being cured.

Vitality Group. This is the part of their business that sells the Vitality model to third parties. This is what excites me most about Discovery. Selling on the preventive healthcare model to other insurers who have millions of clients has huge potential. This also includes corporates who have large employee bases. It benefits the insurers and their clients and it certainly benefits corporates and their healthy employees. Vitality Group now has 1.7 million members. Could this become the biggest healthcare membership in the world? The product certainly has the potential.

Ping An Health has been a slow process but the growth coming through in this last six months is very encouraging. Membership grew by 60%, and the business finally made a decent profit of R36 million. Within this joint venture, there are over 3 million people on the rewards program. They have a great partner in a tough country to crack. The potential here is huge.

These numbers represent good progress in the Discovery story. So many of the goals are becoming realities. We are very happy shareholders and clients of Discovery. This must be the only insurer on the planet that actually has happy clients!




Linkfest, lap it up

Michael's Musings

Do you know that in Japan, only around 10% of houses sold are used houses? Most houses lose their value after 15 - 30 years, as a result Japan compared to the US, has four times as many architects - Why Are Japanese Homes Disposable?




Bright's Banter

Ryan Coogler's Black Panther grossed around $235m at the box office on opening weekend across North America making it the biggest solo superhero, non-sequel, black directed movie of all time. It doesn't end there, it's also the 5th biggest movie debut of all time and the second largest Marvel debut after The Avengers (2012) and the list goes on. This movie is not done breaking records as non-US sales keep flying in.

If you haven't watched the movie yet, stop everything right now and buy tickets tonight for yourself and your loved ones (it's half-price Wednesdays at NuMetro today). Don't forget to dress up and have fun! #WakandaForever. This movie is worth every penny and the reviews such as this one (spoiler free) speak volumes.

Let's see if all this success translates to the well-deserved awards.

Infographic: Black Panther Makes the Top Ten Opening Weekend Blockbuster List | Statista You will find more infographics at Statista




Vestact in the Media

Byron gets a mention in a recent Forbes article - How To Lose $2.1 Billion In One Day.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Our market has been bouncing between red and green, ahead of the budget speech this afternoon. Good news for consumers, our CPI read for January was 4.4%, lower than the corresponding period and economist forecasts. Then expect some currency movements this evening, when the FOMC minutes are released.




Sent to you by Team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Friday, 22 September 2017

The Vital Future of Insurance


To market to market to buy a fat pig. The SARB didn't do what most people were expecting; they left things the same. A Repo rate at 6.75%, means you are still paying the same for your house at month end. As we have spoken about before, certainty is key to economic growth and a stable economy in general. Certainty leads to stability and stability leads to certainty. The reason given for leaving rates unchanged was due to lack of certainty.

    "Given the heightened uncertainties in the economy, the MPC felt it would be appropriate to maintain the current monetary policy stance at this stage and reassess the data and the balance of risks at the next meeting."


The good news is that the Rand strengthened on the announcement, I suspect due to happy bondholders. They next meet at the end of November, where things may be even more uncertain due to the ANC conference in December.

Our market dropped slightly on the MPC news but then recovered and finished flat. US Markets opened in the red and stayed there all day, so no records for the day. Here is the scorecard, the Dow was down 0.24%, the S&P 500 was down 0.3%, the Nasdaq was down 0.52% and the All-share registered a change of 0.00%.




Company corner

Michael's Musings

On Monday there were Full Year numbers from Discovery, which didn't disappoint. The results are broadcast on TV, making it easy to watch and pause if need be. Adrian Gore's passion for the business sure is inspiring. Recent books that I have read all talk about the importance of the vision from a founder. Founders generally have more credibility and business-wide support, meaning they can push companies in directions that professional managers would struggle. Adrian Gore and Stephen Saad are the first two South African leaders that come to mind when I think of inspirational leaders. But we are blessed with many.

Here is a quick look at the group's performance as a whole.



The numbers in pink are their UK operations, which have been hit hard by Brexit. The group estimate's that Brexit has had at 25% impact on the profit for the Vitality Life business, ouch! Looking at the other UK business, Vitality Health, that huge jump in profit is due to the previous period having some once-off costs, so it was coming off a low base. Both UK divisions aren't doing as well as management had previously hoped but are moving in the right direction. Vitality UK is a superior product to traditional medical aid and life insurance. Their marketing is all over the place, you can't watch UK sport now without seeing Vitality branding somewhere.

The human behaviour data they have acquired, unsurprisingly is being put to good use in the UK. When people sign up for the Apple Watch incentive program, they saw a 42% increase in physical activity. From Discovery's perspective that is money well spent.

The Discovery Insure division has clear benefits from the incentives program. The division is still relatively new and falls in the group's 'emerging businesses' segment. Discovery Insure only started making money in the second half of the year and was loss-making for the full year. For 2018 though we should see a nice juicy profit. Their focus on driving quality, has resulted in new customers improving their driving by 27% in the first year on average. Even better, bad drivers are more likely to move to other insurers, meaning they are left with a higher proportion of their book in good drivers.



A bit of shameless Discovery promoting, I am an Insure customer. Since joining, I am more aware of my driving and for my efforts, I get over R1k back a month. The only problem now is that my wife's driving score is substantially higher than mine; I get reminded of that fact frequently.

From an investors perspective, the most exciting part of the business is their JV in China. The number of new customers increased by 428% last year to 3.7 million lives, a drop in the ocean for China. The operation is still loss-making but is expected to reach break-even during next year. Adrian emphasised that they are more focused on building a solid foundation than becoming profitable as soon as possible.



Over the last two-years the Discovery share price is flat, but since January they are up 25%. Part of the concern was that Discovery would need to do another rights issue to fund their international growth and the bank that they are launching in South Africa (expected for the second quarter of 2018). As the year has gone on it became increasingly clear that a rights issue was not needed.

The stock is not cheap at a P/E of 21, when earnings only grew 8% last year. Going forward though, they have a long pipeline of strong profit producing businesses. Their 'emerging businesses' will become more established and the Chinese division has the potential to become their most significant profit centre. We back Adrian Gore's vision for the company and their world-leading IP. A buy in our books.




Linkfest, lap it up

Byron's Beats

Because we are in the industry of equities, we often get inquiries about trading the market. Most of the enquiries come from inexperienced youngsters who have seen glamorous adverts about getting rich quickly from trading, especially forex trading. I like to compare trading to playing golf. Anyone can do it but it takes years and years of practice to actually make money from it. And even with all that practice, many people will still end up losing. It is very difficult. We may have shared this image below before but it deserves another mention. It is called the 90/90/90 Rule of Trading.






Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Asian markets are all in the red this morning, along with our market which opened down 0.3%. OPEC are meeting today, people in the know don't expect anything new to come of the meeting. With Brent trading at $56 a barrel and the Rand in the $/R 13.20's range, a petrol price hike is probably on the cards next month. Enjoy your heritage weekend; I will be putting a big piece of meat on a braai for my heritage day.




Sent to you by Team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Friday, 24 February 2017

Discovering profits anew

"There is something more than the cute rewards program for you the shareholder, and indeed being part of the scheme as a member, alongside incrementally more healthy people. The more healthy the scheme members, the more profitable the scheme, the greater the buffer, the more likely for the scheme to do good by their members."




To market to market to buy a fat pig Yesterday was a tale of two parts to the market. There were the stocks on the one side of the scoreboard that had been impacted by a strengthening Rand, the likes of South32, Richemont, Amplats, AB InBev (and the like) and then those that had results Mr. Market liked (like a lot), and SA inc. stocks. As two of those stocks "concern" us, we will deal with them below in the company corner segment. Session end the Jozi all share index closed at nearly one-fifth of a percent higher, industrials were marginally lower with the legendary childhood book beast, the pushmi-pullyu having a big tug of war match. Remember, the Dr. Dolittle animal, half unicorn and half antelope. Richemont dragging the index lower on the one hand, Bidcorp sending it much higher on the other hand, good results.

I picked up an interesting story from Bloomberg. Remember that whilst objects in the mirror may be closer than they seem, equally past performance is no guarantee for future returns, ok? Someone did a deep dive of all the stock market data available since the turn of the last century, over 116 years worth of data has been crunched and (drum roll again) - List of Top Equity Returns Since 1900 Starts With South Africa. True story sports lovers. Check out the associated graph, courtesy Bloomberg.



The line that I like the most is "Equities were the best performing asset in every country, showing over the long run there has been a reward for higher risk." We all knew that, we just needed some confirmation. And the reason why we did so well? "South Africa performed well partly because it is a resource rich country that has successfully developed into a broader diversified economy, and because it has made a peaceful transition from apartheid and remained stable." Pat yourself on the back. Now you may think that this is all water under the bridge and the future matters (and you are right), the article points out that the Russian and Chinese stock markets as a result of their revolution went to zero in 1917 and 1949 respectively. Zero. Zilch. Nil. And during World War Two, the Japanese stock markets went down by 96 percent. Wow. Just wow. See, revolutions and war are bad for stock markets, capital loses and then humanity is all the poorer for it.

Equally important in this relatively short article is how some businesses once dominated, and then the economy evolved: "In 1900, more than 80 percent of the U.S. stock-market's value was in businesses such as railroads, which are today small or extinct. Nearly half of U.K. companies by value are in sectors that didn't exist a century ago. Gold, once key to South Africa's wealth, has waned in importance and the biggest Australian companies are now banks."

What is the moral of the story? I am not entirely sure. What I do know is that paying attention in stock markets is absolutely vital. If the returns are great over the long run, it means that they are being "made" somewhere else as new industries take the proverbial mantle from older ones. For instance, Naspers has a market capitalisation of 954 billion Rand, 15 years ago the company was struggling to rotate to the internet era. The share price was 12 Rand. Over the last ten years, the Naspers share price has grown over 1000 percent, from around 170 Rand to today. That is a market cap, this time in 2007 of "only" 76 billion Rand. Anglo American on the other hand, has a market capitalisation of 299 billion Rand today. The stock is down 46 percent in ten years. Back then the market cap was around 510 billion Rand. Yes, Anglo was over six and a half times the size of Naspers ten year ago. Now ..... Naspers is over three times the size of Anglo. And you thought things didn't change that much in a hurry?




Across the oceans vast and wide, stocks in New York, New York were mixed, with the nerds of NASDAQ off by around four-tenths of a percent. I saw that NVDA was totalled, the stock down nearly 10 percent, quite a big analyst downgrade (Nvidia's stock rocked after analysts say it's time to sell) was the reason, as far as I could see. I think that this is an excellent business and may be a good opportunity. Tesla also sank over six percent, it was a day when high beta stocks took a whipping. Again, this is to be expected at some level, both sets of stocks have a huge bunch of short speculators around. The trading action of high multiple stocks is always going to be "difficult" to try and nail down. Best you not try!

At the other end of the market, the Dow Jones powered to another record high, powered is perhaps a strong word. The Dow clocked ten up sessions in a row. I saw an interview on CNBC with Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin (Man-nu-chin), in which he was clear that there would be a well thought through tax plan by August recess. Meaning voted and put forward, debated and implemented. This is going to be huge (I think you are goin' to love it). That may have been one of the reasons, industrial America may well be the winners on all of this.

In the end, the Dow popped over 20800 points, up 0.17 percent by the close. Basic materials were the laggards, commodity prices giving back after the Fed "real soon" rates raise is a sign of strength for the Dollar. The US Dollar that is, still the one and only currency of the world. And there I thought that the Rio Tinto numbers were good. The broader market S&P 500 managed a marginal gain, less than a single point gain (0.99 points) or 0.04 percent of a gain. That is all sports lovers!




Company corner

Discovery released interim results for the half year to end December yesterday morning. This is a great business. A business that was conceptualised by an incredible individual who has seen in large part his vision realised. Adrian Gore is not finished. He seems passionate about the business, he walks the walk and he talks the talk. And talk he can. At the results presentation he made it known that Brexit, the weaker Pound to the Rand and the weakness in the investments (statutory capital) in the UK (yields in Gilts powering to an all-time low) has had a negative impact on the UK operations.

The company cannot be responsible in any way for the actions of the UK citizens, and equally how the market responds to that, it is in the grouping of those factors beyond their control. Brexit weighed, when it all eventually settles (it may take a couple of years), it will be easier to have a comparable numbers. Until then, the cost of doing business in the UK, from a mindset point of view too, is going to be exceptionally hard to quantify. As Adrian Gore rightfully pointed out, they (Discovery) will focus on their business. For the record, see the slide below, the UK business "did" 10 percent better in Pound Sterling, negative 8 percent in Rand terms:



For the very first time that I can remember, the company in a slide in their presentation explained the business "trajectory" and route they follow. In other words, what their internal expectations are with the businesses that they start from scratch. For all intents and purposes, Discovery are a disruptor of the status quo, they take an industry that they think needs a shake up and change, they push it in the right direction adding technological innovations and leveraging off the human desire to be better. That is why New Year is such a big thing, people want to always "be better" than last year.

So here is a slide to explain that when the company starts motor vehicle insurance to take on their competitors in the market, what their time horizon is for that business to move into the category of developing and developed business. The three terms you have to remember are, new, emerging and then established.



To cut to the chase, the business for the time being is a Health and Life insurance business, with smaller contributions from the invest business. There are lots of opportunities that are likely to emerge in the coming years, most especially with regards to PingAn, Vitality (white labelling) and of course Discovery Insure. There are over 160 thousand insured vehicles out there, I can count myself one of those. I hate being told that I am about average relative to the other drivers on the road, I guess I am being compared to the average Discovery Insure driver. I suspect that within a year or two, the Discovery Insure business will be profitable, as will the Vitality business.

There is something more than the cute rewards program for you the shareholder, and indeed being part of the scheme as a member, alongside incrementally more healthy people. The more healthy the scheme members, the more profitable the scheme, the greater the buffer, the more likely for the scheme to do good by their members. i.e. All members benefit. What is quite interesting is that the lapse rate is greater if your "status" is lower. i.e. blue or bronze, then you are more likely to think that the expense is not for you. None of Discovery products are cheap, that is for sure.

The stock is not cheap either. It is not expensive either. At 16 times forward, with the growth in their business, through the technology innovations (the most technology savvy insurance business in the world), there is more growth to come. We are pleased with the initial market reaction, we are pleased with the outlook, notwithstanding some problem areas. We continue to accumulate the company.




Linkfest, lap it up

This is a nice problem to have, I think? - Sweden complains it is collecting too much tax. Having negative interest rates meant that some creative companies used the Swedish tax authority as a make shift savings account.

LTE is great! As our phones and computers get more powerful and as we consume more video, 5G will be needed to allow us to get all the data we demand as consumers - Verizon to Begin 5G User Trials in 11 Markets by Middle of Year.

This is a nice visual, it tells you exactly how big or YUGE you think you are, relative to your peers. The $74 Trillion Global Economy in One Chart. There are only a few worth noting of size, the rest of us have to try a lot harder. The good news is that as time goes on, there will be more participants, Indonesia, India and the like (dare I say it Russia, Saudi and Brazil) which will lead to fewer global shocks when a specific economy slows.






Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Claudio Ranieri was sacked 298 days after winning the league, Leicester City are a point away from relegation. True story. Such is the demanding world that we live in. Is this a clear sign that in fairy tales when they say "and they all lived happily ever after", they lied? Oh my word, it is that exciting time again when we all get to read the Warren Buffett letter to the Berkshire Shareholders. It is like a cult following of an old fellow in Omaha, one of the finest investors to have ever walked the planet.



Sent to you by Sasha, Byron and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Wednesday, 7 September 2016

Discovery keeps on keeping on

"I will go buy it. I think that the business understands psychology of the human being well, the rewards system and the look-at-me points system is designed to pit yourself against yourself. And of course against your mates. There are real cash reward benefits for both the policy holders and more importantly the company over time."




To market to market to buy a fat pig The weakest US services PMI read for an absolute age, and whilst the number showed 79 straight months of continued expansion, it was the lowest for six years. Normally nobody would blink too much here, we are however in a rates holding pattern. Mr. Market suggested that a rates rise in September is now solidly off the table alongside the tepid jobs number last week Friday, and the expectations for one and done for a while now shift to December. This results in a weaker Dollar, stronger metal prices and an OK time for stocks.

Earnings are what matter for stocks ultimately, not Fed watching, even if the TV screens tell you something else. Those people can't remember what they said last month. OK, sis, I am being mean, their time frames and livelihoods are very different to ours. Without the solid hustling that is afforded to people who operate in capitalism societies, the financial engineering ideas that we have become used to today wouldn't exist. i.e. If someone questioned something and said, what happens if I did this and or the same thing that way (obviously having an incentive for them), and everyone benefitted, then efficiencies almost always equals improvements. That can only happen where true markets exist.

So whilst I think it is crazy to have fixations on numbers and trading opportunities, and those get the short term attention, the luxury of having instant liquidity is very important. Even though that (older) fellow from Omaha, Warren Buffett, suggests that if you buy something today, you should be comfortable to hold it for five years without the liquidity. I guess that means that his minimum time frame to transact is at least half a decade. Also, for him to sell 10 percent of Wells Fargo is a lot harder than for most people, even if it is 15 percent of their portfolios.

Quick scoreboard check of the US markets from last evening, stocks in New York, New York finished the session up one-quarter of a percent for the blue chip Dow Jones Industrial Average, nearly one-third of a percent better for the S&P 500 and half a percent to the good for the broader market S&P 500. Locally, where the weather is 'lekker' and the rainfall is desperately needed (apparently 40 percent of the water usage in Gauteng is used in residential gardens - dinkum), stocks rose a smidgen. There was a decent enough GDP read, Byron sent through a nice infographic (see why these are important in the links segment). The Rand was stronger as a result of a weak US economic read and the decent GDP read. Next quarter is going to have to be a blockbuster.



We used less electricity, thanks to lower consumption patterns and a warmer winter (that kicked Mr. Price in the kidneys too). Lower inflation on the horizon perhaps means for banks and financials, coupled with the finance sector looking better than anticipated. Make no mistake, it is really tough out there. I can tell from our clients locally, and their savings patterns that it hasn't been easy for local consumers, and these are the richer ones. So next quarter is going to be a tough comparable, the yearly growth is still muted and pretty pathetic, at least we are not Brazil! They are experiencing the worst the drawdown in Brazilian economic contraction since the great depression, and that was a LONG time ago. As they say in the classics, "let's watch it".




Company corner

The first read through of the Discovery annual results revealed that the business is very definitely a growth oriented one. Different businesses in the core market, South Africa, continue to take market share and reinvent short term (and life) insurance, investments and bed down their core business, health insurance. There is a big gap between those that are lucky enough to afford private healthcare in South Africa and those who have to use the public health system, most will agree that the spend to outcomes ratio is not the best, to put it mildly. The Vitality program has undoubtably been a success and I think that we are only starting to scratch the surface. The potential of the existing partnerships in countries like China, with Ping An Insurance and more recently in Canada and the US (John Hancock), as well as some of the bigger economies of Europe represent exciting white labelling of the Vitality product.

One of the mums at the school asked me, why do you work to get the points, if I want a smoothie I will go buy it. I think that the business understands psychology of the human being well, the rewards system and the look-at-me points system is designed to pit yourself against yourself. And of course against your mates. There are real cash reward benefits for both the policy holders and more importantly the company over time. The better shape their policy holders are, be it life, health or short term, or a combination of all three, the less likely they are to claim. The bait of the rewards tussling with the tiger fish competitive nature of their core client is showing through in the Vitality Watch program.

The whole piece about the product launch is worth mentioning in full:

    "The success of Vitality Active Rewards with Apple Watch in changing wellness behaviour and segmenting insurance risk in South Africa and the United States has advanced the science underpinning the Vitality Shared-Value Insurance model. Results over the first six months of the Vitality Active Rewards benefit showed dramatic and sustained behaviour change, with a 20% increase in physical activity for those who engaged in the benefit, and 81% for those who also took the Apple Watch. This is the most successful benefit to date, as measured by take-up and engagement, and shows strong initial insurance applications, with engaged members demonstrating significantly lower morbidity and mortality experience than other Vitality members."


Simply by undertaking to get the Apple Watch and maintain a certain fitness level, the Vitality users have gotten far healthier. There are tangible results for the business and the product is in its infancy. A significant amount of data is already being collected no doubt around the user patterns. Steps, heart rate (resting and exercising), flights climbed, and so on. The measure is not perfect, for example, my wife has a very low resting heart rate, in the forties and physically struggles to get her heart rate up. So obviously the loose calculations of 70 and then 80 percent of maximum heart rate doesn't work for all and sundry. It is no doubt work in progress.

By offering compelling and premium products that disrupt the norm, as we know it, the company has been able to grow from a standing start at the dawn of a democratic South Africa, to the dominant operator in some of their businesses. Of course the banking ramp up (branchless I guess) and roll out is going to cost a lot of money, and that is why the share price didn't react positively to the good results. At face value, like I said in the introduction, the results looked good. The spend and roll out of existing businesses will suck capital, you must know as a shareholder that the business is definitely a growth one, and not going to be priced in the same way as traditional insurers or financials. What sets the company apart is that they have a compelling product that they are able to white label globally. We maintain our buy rating and will continue to roll out some commentary in the coming days, including observations of ours.




Linkfest, lap it up

This is of course an infographic (what else, as Gorge Clooney would say) - 13 Scientific Reasons Explaining Why You Crave Infographics. I like points 5 and 6, we receive 5 times as much information today as we did in 1986 and we consume (outside of work) 100,500 words a day. How much do we remember? Turns out more if it is a picture! So if a picture was a 1000 words, you would only need to see 100 a day outside of work then?

Snapchat is growing like gangbusters. Advertising Revenues reported in 2015 were around 60 million Dollars, expectations are for 1.76 billion Dollars in 2018. Phenomenal. It is a pretty cool platform, perhaps the valuations are still too aggressive though. Decide yourself, either way, well done to the owners of the platform for not selling - Snapchat Ad Revenue to Reach $935 Million in 2017.

Are there going to be more of doing this in the future? - Life at the Nowhere Office What does it mean for office space, what does it mean for expectations from employers, what does it mean for formal workflow? Some businesses need everyone to be together, increasingly there are businesses where that doesn't need to happen. Would you, or do you work better on the run?




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks globally are mixed. Of course the most exciting thing to happen today will be the Apple event, that takes place after market this side. Expectations are for a new phone and no cord for your earphones, we are going cordless people. Beats already makes tons of cordless headsets, they are far more expensive than the ones with cords. Let us wait and not speculate about what they are likely to be, or not, and whether there are new Macs or tablets or new Apple watch.





Sent to you by Sasha, Byron and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Friday, 22 July 2016

Stryke while the price is down

"As you know, we really like the sector, it is changing, growing and getting exceptionally better as we speak. Our job is to find the best companies who are spearheading this change. Stryker is certainly one of them, we reiterate our buy rating."




To market to market to buy a fat pig Oh no, the little steam engine of the Dow Jones variety did not make it to the top of the hill. There is an enormous amount of company related news that we have to deal with, we should definitely bounce directly into these events immediately. As we say, we do companies and not economies and announcements from governments. And global bodies and their predictions. Besides, who remembers what the last one was, or the one from five years ago? Or what it is likely to be in five years time? You don't know what is going to transpire, I don't know, collectively we can work towards what we think is reasonable.

Before we do a quick scoreboard check, there was a rates decision locally yesterday. The trajectory for inflation was lowered in the long run (out of the band in the short term), that is a good thing. What is not good is that the trajectory for growth was also lowered. To flat. Eish, it is tough out there chaps. It certainly doesn't always feel like it in the big bad Jozi, things are always going on. Whilst this lovely province off ours hustles and bustles and is filled with economic activity that is ahead of the rest of the country in terms of the contribution, it does not represent all of South Africa. Don't make that mistake, the cranes in Sandton might represent what is happening in the most powerful economic hub across the continent, it certainly isn't the lived reality of many ordinary South Africans.

That said, we should be grateful that we are not Turkey, or Russia, it hardly looks that encouraging politically in those parts of the world. We have elections in a couple of weeks, if not national ones, perhaps the more important bread and butter issues around municipalities. At the end of the day, all people want is accountability. If we deliver you consistently poor returns, no matter what we say, you are going to pull money.

The same is true for Bill Ackman, the hedge fund manager according to Yahoo! finance made his conference call sound like a victory lap, after getting "stomped". He may well be right on Herbalife, the market always has deeper pockets than you. Remember that. That almost buried Michael Burry, he was right in the end. The eccentric drum playing fund manager, who could have been a full time neurologist, was wrong forever during a time the market flew. He ended up being very right. If you haven't read the Big Short or watched the movie, definitely read up about the weird antics and his ability to crunch the numbers better, and to hustle. Strangely, last I read of him is that he advocated growing food and sending it across to places with less water. Yip.

Scoreboard check quickly, the Dow Jones fell for the first time in over 8 sessions, down over four-tenths of a percent by the end of the session. The nerds of NASDAQ lost just over one-third of a percent and the broader market S&P 500 was somewhere in-between the two. Well, records are there to be broken, earnings are going to continue to drive share prices and broader markets. Financials, in a very tough environment have been able to stay extremely profitable. Intel was weaker during the session, the stock has been completely flat since the beginning of the year, over the last 12 months the stock has returned a little over 16 percent, that sounds pretty darn good. The last two years have been a slog however, most chip makers in the PC and server space have struggled. The Internet of Things is likely to change that.

Talking of which, on the local front Vodacom reported subscriber numbers that were good, having gained market share here in South Africa. As we saw however from that Cisco report about the internet of things the other day when we covered the MTN trading update - 6 month trading update - swing to loss, there will be 1.5 devices connected per person by 2020. If you think that is a lot, just look around at your phone, your computer, perhaps an iPad and even a fitness device. There, you account for four already, comfortably ahead of the rest.

Locally stocks slid off the highs into the close, we did still however manage to end the day in the green, up just a smidgen over one-quarter of a percent by the time all was said and done. Industrials lower, resources much (much) higher on the session. Financials up the same amount as the market. Vodacom was the biggest loser on the day, down two and one-quarter of a percent, Amplats soared over six percent, whilst Glencore added over four. Shoprite gave a little back after a magic day in the session prior (up over ten percent), the stock is still flirting with multi month highs. And with the inflation outlook improving, perhaps they would be the first beneficiaries. The market is telling you exactly this, Pikwik, Massmart and Pick n Pay all clocking new 12 month highs during the session. Into company news sports lovers, dive below the line to find it.




Company corner

Discovery made an announcement yesterday that needed closer and further inspection. The headline reads Discovery to introduce Vitality to Japan. Japan of course is a country with over 125 million people, where the average age is around 45 and is possibly one of (if not the) most sophisticated societies on the planet. Organisational skills and attention to detail is not lacking.

OK, so how do discovery plan to do all of this? Simple, at least if you read it at face value - "a strategic partnership with Sumitomo Life Insurance Co. (Sumitomo Life) and SoftBank Corporation (SoftBank) that will see shared value insurance introduced to the Japanese life insurance market through the joint development of insurance products incorporated with Vitality, Discovery's globally recognised wellness programme."

Sumitomo is an insurer that is over 100 years old, it produces profits in excess of 3 billion Dollars per annum, it is headquartered in Osaka (my aunt used to live there), employs over 42 thousand people and most impressive, has policies in place in excess of 1.1 trillion Dollars. Individual life insurance is where their business is at, from their website:



If the Vitality program can boost the company profitability by making those with life insurance eke out a few more years (by having healthier habits) then the payout ratio is extended. Life insurance is a what if I die before I have accumulated enough assets purchase, before I pay down my debt. It is designed to give the remaining behind people, if you happen to die before the actuarial calculations say you will, the same life style that they would have afforded you in the past. There are different forms of life insurance that are also designed to act as investment products, obviously the costs increase as you get older, none of us are Benjamin Button.

For companies such as Sumitomo, it makes sense to use the tried and tested Vitality model. The model is not too dissimilar to the Tesla one, each and every day that data is being sent back to the databases to be crunched by Vitality, the better the systems become. By being healthy, eating right, most importantly exercising and generally being responsible, the company is able to get a better idea of your risk to them. Doing it slightly differently is Discovery, eking out small percentages on giant amounts makes these companies a LOT more profitable and subsequently, the savings are shared as spoils, this is where you benefit as a Discovery shareholder. Softbank, you may recognise that company, they are real operators and I suspect a great partner to be introduced to for the Discovery team. A net positive, the share price rallied one and a half percent on the day.




Visa takes you places. Visa will be in your face over the coming weeks as a Worldwide Olympic Partner, those are two weeks away sports lovers. An amazing thing really, the Olympic Games, this one will of course be no exception. Equally, Visa is an amazing company. Their ability to run a network that will switch your transaction in a single swipe, regardless of whether you are in any of the major cities of the world and regardless of where your bank is. The fact that there can be guaranteed payment to the merchant, no cash ever exchanges hands and your risks are greatly reduced, that part you just take for granted. We don't even bat an eye.

Yet payment methods continue to evolve to the point where no physical card will be produced, you can with your thumbprint exercise your right to acquire the goods. Just like that. Remember travellers cheques? I remember going on Honeymoon with a whole lot (back then a kings ransom) of them, changing them, fees and all. Visa, along with all the switching networks will be at the forefront of the new technologies, nobody wants to reinvent the wheel just yet. Apple Pay still requires your "card", even if in the future you won't ever produce the physical. If you know your card verification value (the last three digits on the back) in many cases you can complete an online transaction without ever having to see your card again.

Visa numbers from last evening quickly, this was for their third quarter. The meet on the revenue line was also met with a beat on earnings, slightly ahead of Wall Street expectations. The company has also made the share buyback larger, to 7.3 billion Dollars. The market cap last evening was 189 billion Dollars, this represents a really large amount, shareholders only feel the impact much later. Fewer shares in issue with incrementally increasing earnings.

Volumes continue to increase in the low double digits, as consumers and governments are encouraged to do more digitally. We often point out that many transactions are still cash in Europe, the more done with cards, the cheaper it gets eventually for everyone. Visa Europe was integrated into the company, the total consideration remember was upfront 12.2 billion Euros, plus an extra Pref share issuance of 5.3 billion Euros and a closing 1 billion plus 4 percent per annum in interest on the third anniversary of closing. In total around 21 and a half billion Dollars. A truly big deal! Part of the buyback is to minimise the impact of the prefs issued here.

The stock has always looked perpetually expensive. Now is no exception either. Even with guidance given of high single digit revenue growth, margins to die for and the ability to generate free cash of 7 billion Dollars per annum, the market always has high expectations. There are an astonishing 2.5 billion cards out there. According to this report from competitor MasterCard, "cash still accounts for 85% of all consumer transactions throughout the world." A non-cash (i.e. Electronic and Card) payment transactions are understandably at a much lower percentage in developing countries than developed countries. Still, there is plenty of room for growth, as you can see -



We suspect that Visa and the others who operate the networks for switching will continue to benefit from all the switching away from cash. I am pretty sure that cash as we know it is living on borrowed time, at least in more developed societies. The carrying costs are too high, it needs to be guarded and buried in a hole in the ground. Sounds like gold. We continue to accumulate what is a very well positioned business that benefits from globalisation and changing consumer patterns. The stock price is flat after-hours.




Sometimes markets work in mysterious ways. Last night Stryker beat earnings estimates, but lowered expectations for next quarter. The stock is down 4% premarket. The reason I am perplexed is because they actually raised estimates for the full year. Estimates for the year increased, but the market is only focussing on next quarter. Sounds like an opportunity to me. Long term shareholders will not be too upset however, the stock is up nearly 30% year to date and it is the best performing stock in the Vestact portfolio so far this year. Let us look at the numbers.

When reporting sales the medical devices business splits their sales into 3 categories. Net sales for the group grew 16.8% to $2.8bn, 6.6% if you exclude acquisitions. The image below not only shows you these three categories but it further details the divisions.



As you can see, the acquisition of Sage Products and Physio Control International had a strong impact on the MedSurg division. If you click on the links and browse through the websites it is pretty impressive seeing all the new products and devices they are coming up with to improve our standard of living. Your body is your greatest tool, these are the devices that will fix it. What bigger priority can you have than the physical well being of yourself and your loved ones? Back to the numbers.

This growth in sales resulted in a 15.8% increase in earnings to $1.39 for the quarter. That is excluding the costs and intangible write downs form the acquisitions. Gross margins are a whopping 66.2% and operating income margin came in at 24.8%. They sure do charge you for these high end products. It is an incredibly profitable business. 10% of these gross profits goes back into Research and Development. Trading at $118 a share and expecting full year earnings of $5.75 the stock trades just above 20 times. Slightly above the S&P500 forward average of 17, and current trailing 19.3 times.

When you look at the quality of the business, I am not surprised. The majority of doctors we speak to rave about their products. If you work in healthcare and have some extra insights please let us know what you think of Stryker products. Having said that, 72% of their sales comes from the US (although they seem to have a decent presence in SA). This presents a good opportunity for global expansion.

Another exciting prospect could come from further acquisitions. There is a huge amount of innovation in the healthcare sector and products are being created all the time independently. Stryker has a market cap of $46bn and is sitting on $3bn in cash. I am sure there are lots of consolidation opportunities.

As you know, we really like the sector, it is changing, growing and getting exceptionally better as we speak. Our job is to find the best companies who are spearheading this change. Stryker is certainly one of them, we reiterate our buy rating.




Linkfest, lap it up

Two of our US holding are teaming up to help save students money (and grow their market share) - Amazon and Wells Fargo Team Up to Offer Cheaper Student Loans

Following on from our Tesla piece yesterday, batteries are a very big factor as to whether Elon Musk's dreams will come true - Our Energy Problem: Putting the Battery in Context. As you can see batteries still have a very long way to go until they are in the leagues of other energy sources.



Streaming has already won the music wars, who will win the streaming wars is the next question. Who wins the streaming wars will also impact how artists will be paid for their content going forward - Apple wants a 'simpler and more transparent' royalty scheme for music that would also seriously hurt Spotify.

The more people I speak to about finances, the more you realise that it is an area where society does not understand enough - Nearly two-thirds of Americans can't pass a basic 5-question financial literacy test, can you?. I was apprehensive to take the test but glad to say that I managed to get 6 out of 6.




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. Stocks across the globe are lower, we are off the best levels, I am guessing that we shouldn't complain now should we. So far on the earnings front there haven't been too many disappointments and I am sure in the coming months we are going to see a return to normality. Whatever Mario Draghi and his team, and Janet Yellen and her team do, they will do. That goes without saying, they definitely are given stick, yet everyone equally wants their comfort blankey from the central banks.



Sent to you by Sasha, Byron and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063

Monday, 29 February 2016

Get Active

"If your life insurance payouts don't happen (before they become more expensive to keep), then the company is more profitable. And all this they do by changing your behaviour, getting you to raise your heart rate 5 or so times a week, drive better and eat better. It seems so simple, and with all the data that they have collected recently, it is working."




To market to market to buy a fat pig The Oscar goes to ... OK, that is all good and well, if you haven't heard by now, Leo finally won. For a movie that he grunts in. I haven't seen it yet, I don't get out much, sorry. There are no investing Oscars, perhaps Buffett and Berkshire would have the most nominations and wins if there were. The Al Pacino, Jack Nicholson and Robert De Niro rolled into one. Or if acting was one category, gender neutral, Buffett would be the Meryl Streep of investing.

Perhaps the reason that there is no Oscars for investing is that the markets measure you, that is your award. Mr. Market is measured from year to year. The market decides on what the price a security or bond or level is supposed to be, relative to the risk assumed. The Rand has suffered from a bout of weakness recently as a result of political meddling, or seemingly political interference. I for one hope this is resolved quickly. There are some things that you cannot change, politics is certainly in that category.

On Friday in Jozi, Jozi, stocks closed much higher, up over two percent on the day. In large part thanks to a stronger finish on Wall Street the session prior, also the weaker Rand boosted some of the Rand hedges. Barclays Africa (which may need a name change) fell on the worst kept secret in town, that the parent company is looking to divest from their stake down here, as part of their global introspection. The announcement is supposedly going to come tomorrow, 1 March. Remember that this is a day that comes around once every four years, leap day. They (Barclays) own 62.3 percent of the locally listed entity. The only question is, who is the buyer? And what is the price? Eish, tough decisions in a tough time.

Stocks across the ocean, in New York, New York, were mixed, tech stocks ended the session marginally higher, whilst the S&P 500 closed down one-fifth (nearly) and the Dow Jones Industrials closed down a little over one-third on the day. Oil prices continue to be the goto for sentiment, Chinese markets are in meltdown mode this morning. Eish. Not to worry, read the Buffett note lower on optimism in general.




Company corner

Discovery, that company that we had a short look at on Friday deserves a better look. Bright, our newest and best colleague, was supposed to go, time definitely got the better of him. He is young, and that is what you need in the industry, young people who understand and know the history of the stock market, yet their lived experiences don't include the big drawdowns. I suspect that as you go on, it becomes that you are more cynical, in general. That is why it is refreshing when older people become more optimistic as their lived experiences actually improve in time. Just an observation actually, I could tell through the Adrian Gore presentation of the results that they are very proud of their business and their achievements.

In this set of interim results, it became apparent that Discovery are investing hard in their business. An intent from their side to enter banking, 13 percent of earnings was spent in this last 6 months to end December. There is a banking licence application process ongoing, recruitment of quality staff and of course the building of the infrastructure for the fully-fledged retail bank. Thinking out loud here, the bank is going to possibly have the virtual branch model, not too dissimilar to Investec. I think.

The insurance business, short term that is, has flattened a little. As we pointed out Friday, Discovery chases quality business. What is also interesting is that through the broker network the quality of the business is better. i.e. they have a lower loss ratio when signed on by a broker network. Perhaps it is easier to terminate a relationship with an institution than it is with an organisation. You don't "know" the institution, you do the broker.

Discovery is a behavioural changing business, they try and take your habits and try and mend (and bend) them towards better behaviour. Better behaviour for your health, in terms of eating better and getting rewards back on your basket of healthy foods, better driving in terms of braking/acceleration/speeding/night driving, and of course the big one, exercise. The take up of the Discovery Watch is a testament to that, the fact that people are prepared to pair their health vitals with the company, that will lead to the business incentivising their members more.

The more sedentary you are, the more likely you are to have lifestyle dread diseases. If the company can (in the words of Virgin Active, a partner of theirs) make you "get off your arse today" and get you to exercise for small rewards, then it is in their interest long term. If your life insurance payouts don't happen (before they become more expensive to keep), then the company is more profitable. And all this they do by changing your behaviour, getting you to raise your heart rate 5 or so times a week, drive better and eat better. It seems so simple, and with all the data that they have collected recently, it is working. See the below image.



It is amazing at how quick they can tell that someone is changing their behaviour (12 months) and how people are being cross sold across the product lines. i.e. four-fifths of their insure products already had another Discovery product. Quite possibly the starting point is with the Health product.

I think that this is a business that hasn't even scratched the surface. The health and wellness theme is huge, I see more people buying sporting equipment than ever before, I see more people concerned about what they eat than at any other stage in history. The stock always looks perpetually expensive, it is however a growth company, and we are always prepared to pay up for quality. Discovery remains a buy in our book. At the full year stage we will have a look at the valuations in more detail.




Drop everything! Read the Buffett message over the weekend. First, go to the Berkshire Hathaway website. Per Dollar market capitalisation this must be the worst corporate website in the world. The worst looking of course. The information that you get from the Berkshire Annual Report is amongst the finest in the industry. The simplicity of the writing is genius. Thanks Uncle Warren for everything, most of the folks reading are not even shareholders. The shareholders over the 5 decades have been made very rich.

Berkshire does some interesting things. Rephrase, they have commitment, long holding periods, and more patience than most. They still remain true to their values, they are passionate about sweating the detail. Buffett points out the differences between his style and the fellows over at 3G Capital (the chaps behind the SABMiller buyout), suggesting that they (3g) sweat costs. 3G and Berkshire are partners in the Kraft Heinz investment. See what Uncle Warren says about their (3G Capital) "style", perhaps this is more insight into how they will integrate SABMiller into AB InBev:

    "Their method, at which they have been extraordinarily successful, is to buy companies that offer an opportunity for eliminating many unnecessary costs and then - very promptly - to make the moves that will get the job done. Their actions significantly boost productivity, the all-important factor in America's economic growth over the past 240 years. Without more output of desired goods and services per working hour - that's the measure of productivity gains - an economy inevitably stagnates."


At the corner of everything is doing the same, or more, with less. Farming is a great example of how humanity uses the same amount of land to gain far greater yields over time. Same land and square area, more mouths to feed, far greater and better outcome. Last and only other point that I think is worth sharing about the US economy, Uncle Warren is ever the optimist (and realist). First the background, he talks about the average GDP per capita in the US being 6 times in real terms higher than when he was born in 1930. And then he suggest how commentators bemoan the 2 percent per annum GDP growth. Warren then sticks it into perspective:

    "America's population is growing about .8% per year (.5% from births minus deaths and .3% from net migration). Thus 2% of overall growth produces about 1.2% of per capita growth. That may not sound impressive. But in a single generation of, say, 25 years, that rate of growth leads to a gain of 34.4% in real GDP per capita. (Compounding's effects produce the excess over the percentage that would result by simply multiplying 25 x 1.2%.) In turn, that 34.4% gain will produce a staggering $19,000 increase in real GDP per capita for the next generation. Were that to be distributed equally, the gain would be $76,000 annually for a family of four. Today's politicians need not shed tears for tomorrow's children."


Obviously, as he points out, those who have the skills will be better off than others, lobbying in the capital of the nation will always be a growth industry. Sad, true. And then lastly, for all the doomsayers, who keep pointing out that the US is finished, too much debt, too much crass consumerism and so on, a simple line still holds true: "For 240 years it's been a terrible mistake to bet against America, and now is no time to start."

So the guy is amazing. He, and Charlie Munger, continue to invest and grow the business as he has done for longer than most Wall Streeters have been alive. That in itself is an unparalleled record, perhaps some of the Hedge Funders of today may get close to that record should they avoid huge pitfalls over decades. The only question I ever have is the one that can never be answered. If Berkshire Hathaway over five decades had a three times dividend cover policy (i.e. pay out one-third of earnings as dividends), what would the long term returns have been? Obviously Berkshire wouldn't have been able to use the cashflows to acquire and bolt on complimentary businesses. Berkshire seem to love the people they work with.

The stock market has sold the stock off 10.39 percent over the last 12 months. Over five years the stock is up a staggering 55 percent. No yield. Ever. You get your upside if you sell the stock. And then pay the taxes. Don't ever sell is his message I think. Obviously you may have to at some stage. It is not a stock that we actively recommend. You could of course own the B class shares (131 Dollars apiece), unless you are in the business of buying one A class share, 198,190.50 Dollars apiece. At the current exchange rate that equals 3,195,798.82 Rand a share. Why, oh why, Grandad did you not buy a few back in the late 60's? More on reaction below in links:




Linkfest, lap it up

Over the weekend Buffett published his annual shareholders letter, here are a few bloggers views on the man and his letter.

Ben Carlson looks at peoples reactions to Buffett himself - The Buffett Backlash

Cullen Roche reminds us that one of the themes in Buffett's letters over the years is that the world is not ending and that the future looks bright - Warren Buffett's Greatest Strength. Cullen signs off with the following observation:

    "In a period of global economic weakness and excessive short-termism, it can be helpful to be reminded that there will always be challenges in the short-term. And while it would be irrational to be excessively optimistic all the time, it's useful to remember that the greatest deterrent to most people's wealth accumulation remains their excessive focus not on what can go right in the future, but on what might go wrong."


Some fun facts from Business Insider - 14 stunning facts about Warren Buffett and his wealth




Home again, home again, jiggety-jog. The Indian budget is ongoing. This country no doubt has the ability to grow at a pace and use resources to an extent that China did in the last decade, being a democracy without the central planning capability (and possibly resources) on that sort of scale is just too hard. Talking about things that are too hard, the Chinese market has halved since June last year. Well, nearly, down 48 percent as we speak. Another large swoon today as the Yuan is weakened by the authorities.

And in the biggest news of the day, (for me at least) Starbucks is opening up shop in Italy. Yes, the country that Howard Schultz visited in order to gain insight into coffee culture, he is there and competing. It may be a war of the simple caffe against (and I found this online): "A venti, half-whole milk, one quarter 1%, one quarter non-fat, extra hot, split quad shots (1 1/2 shots decaf, 2 1/2 shots regular), no foam latte, with whip, 2 packets of splenda, 1 sugar in the raw, a touch of vanilla syrup and 3 short sprinkles of cinnamon." What the hell? Just throw some milk with my espresso, that is it!




Sent to you by Sasha and Michael on behalf of team Vestact.

Email us

Follow Sasha, Michael, Byron, Bright and Paul on Twitter

078 533 1063